Temperature gage for engine cooling water reads too hot

5 posts / 0 new
Last post
Stevenjones's picture
Stevenjones
Offline
Joined: 6/29/07
Posts: 74
Temperature gage for engine cooling water reads too hot

Greetings sailors - C36 #2164 MkII  2003 model year:
.  My engine temp gage has been showing 180 deg when cruising.  I've tried and tried to find the cause. 1) Removed the HX  Heat Exchanger boiled out, repainted. Replaced, checked hoses, replaced two.
2) checked the raw water thru hull for clogs.
3) replaced the thru hull to strainer hose
4) check the raw water strainer
5) replaced the thermostat
6) replaced the temp sending unit, checked to make sure the elect connection was intact
7) changed the raw water pump (finally) to an Oberdorfer
​8) even bought one of those cool infared temp gages, read about 160 deg at the thermostat after warming up to running temp.  Odd I thought.
​Still the gage reads 180 deg!
I decided to boil a pan of water, insert the removed temp sending unit (with connection and ground) into the pan of water with a digital thermometer   With the ignition on (engine nor running of course), and as the water slowly cooled in the pan with the sending unit, my wife read off the helm gage.  I compared to my digital readings of the cooling water in the pan.
Results:  The temp gage was reading 20 deg too high!
Before I replace the temp gage and a calibrated sending unit, I want to ask this group if temp gages can be adjusted.  Thinking the back side may have an adjustment screw?  Thoughts?
 

Steven Jones

C36/375IA FaceBook group administrator

C36/375IA Jib Sheet Editor 2012

Seal Beach, CA, USA
C36 #2164 Maléna  2003 Mk-II SRig/FullK,  Long Beach, CA

stevenjones21@gmail.com

LeslieTroyer's picture
LeslieTroyer
Offline
Joined: 3/13/16
Posts: 533

Don’t think so.  You might get the temp correct at one reading and be way off at another.  A single screw can’t correct for that. 

Les

Les & Trish Troyer
Mahalo 
Everett, WA
1983 C-36 Hull #0094
C-36 MK 1 Technical Editor. 

Commodore

 

ROAM's picture
ROAM
Offline
Joined: 5/24/17
Posts: 29

I just discovered the same gauge inaccuracies and confirmed it with my mechanic. At idle, or say 2000 RPM it sits about right @ 165. Higher RPM's our feel tests and digital temp checks at key spots show the engine at 170 or below and gauge is at 180-190. I'm going to check with Universal and or consider a higher quality gauge/sender combo. Prob replace the volt gauge with oil pressure gauge at the same time.

Greg 
ROAM 
C36 MkII 2001
SF Bay

Haro's picture
Haro
Offline
Joined: 11/7/14
Posts: 405

Why not remove the gauge and wire it directly to the sending unit with an external 12v battery. This will check if there is a bad connection wiring on the boat. I would do this at home, that is completely independent of the boat. Use kitchen thermometer in the heated water to check accuracy. If you decide to replace the gauge, repeat this test before installing to confirm that you have located the problem.

bdeliman
Offline
Joined: 8/24/15
Posts: 43

In 2015 I bought my 1989, and found the temp gauge reading 200+. I used a heat sensing gun/sensor and it read 180 at the thermostat housing. The wiring from the engine compartment to the cockpit gauge panel was corrroded. I rewired by running a thick red/black to the panel and a smaller multi wire for the other wires.

Bill Deliman

Vivacious 2
1989 Catalina 36, Tall Rig, Wing Keel, m25xp
Atlantic Highlands, N.J.

Log in or register to post comments